These notes settle the terms we use across the magazine. They are not rules we enforce on anyone's home and they are not a scoring system. They exist so that a recommendation in one article means the same thing in the next, and so that you can tell where our judgment stops and your own preference starts.
Four tests run through every room we describe: proportion, daylight, routine and reversibility. Each one is a question you can ask yourself in an afternoon, without buying anything. When an article says a piece of furniture "works", it usually means the piece passed at least three of these four in the room it was written about.
Two supporting ideas sit underneath those tests. Material honesty means a surface is allowed to look like what it is, including how it ages. A restrained palette of warm cream, natural wood and muted olive green keeps comparisons fair, since a room judged against a loud scheme is judged against a different problem. Neither idea is a requirement for your home. They are the conditions under which our articles were written.
The same four tests apply whether the subject is a living room, a bedroom, a kitchen worktop or shallow storage, which is why advice stays consistent from one piece to the next. If you want to see the reasoning applied to a specific room, the article collection is the place to start, and the mission page explains why we work this way.
Your choice
This site stores your cookie choice in your browser's local storage. Nothing is sent anywhere, and the record stays until you clear it.
You can accept or decline below. Either way, the page keeps working the same.
Details in the privacy policy.